Mariner Wealth Advisors plans deferred compensation around moving states by checking one thing first: whether your payout schedule runs at least ten years, which federal law protects from your former state's tax. Under 4 U.S.C. §114, a state may not tax a nonresident on nonqualified deferred compensation paid in substantially equal periodic installments over at least 10 years, or over life or life expectancy. Lump sums and shorter schedules can still be taxed by the state where the pay was earned.
The numbers show why. In the hypothetical below, a 5-year schedule leaves $36,000 of old-state tax on a $600,000 balance, and a 10-year schedule leaves none.
Most executives hear one tip: move to a no-income-tax state before the payments start. That is only half right, because the schedule, not the new address, decides whether the old state can still tax each installment. Mariner Wealth Advisors wrote this page for executives who hold deferred compensation and are weighing where to retire.
By Sarah Chen, CFP — Senior Financial Planner | Reviewed by Linda Foster, CPASarah has guided families through retirement transitions for over fifteen years, specializing in tax-efficient withdrawal strategies.
Elections are made years before a move, so we read each deferral year's form before anyone talks about a new address.
CPA and Tax Director, Mariner Wealth Advisors
A 10-year schedule only helps if you can wait for the money. We'd keep two years of spending in cash first.
CFP® and Lead Advisor, Mariner Wealth Advisors
The ten-year line in federal law
Here is the rule in plain words. The federal statute, 4 U.S.C. §114, bars a state from taxing a former resident's nonqualified deferred compensation if it is paid in substantially equal periodic payments over 10 years or more, or over the person's life or life expectancy.
Excess benefit plans, which only restore benefits capped by IRS limits, are protected whatever the payment period. Ordinary elective deferral plans need the 10-year or lifetime schedule.
A lump sum, a 5-year schedule, or an uneven schedule with a large final payment generally falls outside the protection. The source state can then tax it as nonresident income.
Federal income tax is the same wherever you live. Only the state layer changes.
If you expect to leave the state where you earned your deferrals, choose substantially equal payments over at least 10 years (or lifetime) for the money you can wait for. Assume any shorter schedule or lump sum can still be taxed by the old state.
Can your old state tax installments after you move?
Yes, when the schedule runs under 10 years or the payments aren't substantially equal. In that case the state where you earned the deferrals can tax each installment as nonresident income, and some states actively audit former executives.
Rental income works differently. Income from real property is taxed by the state where the property sits, so moving doesn't remove it.
Some states have no income tax, and some exempt certain retirement income. Check both the old state's nonresident rules and the new state's rules, since this article is general education and not tax advice.
Hypothetical: Natalie's five installments against ten
Natalie, 51, is CFO of a mid-cap industrial manufacturer, married to a part-time architect, with two teenagers and a 5x-salary stock ownership guideline. She expects about $600,000 in her company's deferred plan when she retires at 60, and she plans to move to a state with no income tax. Her husband also owns a rental condo in their current state that nets $30,000 a year. Assume a flat 6% old-state rate, for illustration, and no growth. Five installments of $120,000 stay taxable by the old state: $120,000 × 6% = $7,200 a year, or $36,000 in total. Ten installments of $60,000 are protected under §114, so the old-state tax is $0. The condo rent is taxed by the old state either way: $30,000 × 6% = $1,800 a year, or $18,000 over ten years. The move removes the tax on the deferred pay, but not on the rent. Our calculator can run this kind of comparison with your own figures.
Now the mistake. Following the generic tip to establish residency in a no-tax state before payments start, too literally, leaves a 5-year schedule fully taxable by the old state. For Natalie, that costs about $36,000.
The arithmetic
The mistake
| Item | 5 installments | 10 installments |
|---|---|---|
| Payment each year | $120,000 | $60,000 |
| Old-state tax each year | $7,200 | $0 |
| Old-state tax in total | $36,000 | $0 |
| Years money stays with employer | 5 | 10 |
| Condo rent tax over 10 years | $18,000 | $18,000 |
Documents and numbers to gather
Start with the plan document and the summary plan description, both on the HR or benefits portal. They list the payout options the plan allows: lump sum, 5 or 10 annual installments, or other schedules.
Pull your signed distribution election form for each plan year, since elections often differ by deferral year. Add the latest account statement showing the balance by year of deferral.
Bring last year's state and federal returns, which show how your current state taxes your wages. Add a projected balance at your planned retirement age, assuming 5% a year for illustration.
Then list your residency evidence for after the move:
- Driver's license and voter registration
- The deed or lease on your primary home
- Where your car is registered
- Where your doctors are
Does the order of moving and electing matter?
Yes. The payout schedule is usually locked when you make the deferral election, which generally happens before the year you earn the pay, years before any move. Moving first doesn't change a schedule already in place.
Acting too late has a hard limit. Under Section 409A, a change to the schedule must be made at least 12 months before the first scheduled payment, must push that payment back at least 5 years, and takes effect only after 12 months.
Acting too early costs too. Someone who moves before retirement while still working in the old state keeps earning wages that state taxes, and often invites a residency audit.
Selling the old home after the first payments arrive weakens the case that your domicile changed on the move date.
Two households, two schedules
Natalie expects to move to a no-income-tax state at 60 and has a stable household budget. A 10-year schedule fits her because the state saving is large and she has other assets to draw on.
Picture a second hypothetical executive with a serious health diagnosis and heavy costs expected within 5 years. A shorter schedule, or a lump sum, can be the better choice even with the state tax, because access to the money matters more.
The protection is worth the most to people who will really leave the source state and can wait for the money. It does nothing if you stay put, or move from a state that doesn't tax the income anyway.
| Factor | Natalie | Second executive |
|---|---|---|
| Planned move | No-tax state at 60 | Unclear |
| Cash needs | Stable budget | Heavy costs within 5 years |
| Other assets | Yes | Limited |
| Likely schedule | 10 equal installments | Shorter or lump sum |
| Main priority | State tax saving | Access to money |
Will a longer schedule still hold up if health or the law changes?
Mostly, but not without trade-offs. A 10-year schedule leaves your money as an unsecured promise of the employer for longer, and it is hard to reverse under 409A. Our deferred compensation planning service covers the employer credit side.
Congress could amend §114, and your new state could add an income tax. Because the schedule is hard to undo, you leave room elsewhere.
Mariner Wealth Advisors keeps two years of spending in a taxable account and diversifies the company stock first. A weak market year or a large medical bill then doesn't push you into changing the schedule. Our concentrated stock articles show what it costs in tax to sell low-basis shares.
Markets and employer finances can fall, and you could lose money, including the amount deferred.
Steps in order for a planned move
Work through these in sequence. The table after the list shows who owns each task.
1) Read the plan's payout options in the plan document. 2) Confirm which deferral years carry which election. 3) Ask a CPA how the old state treats nonresident installments under 10 years. 4) If a move is likely, choose 10-year equal installments for new deferrals before the next annual election window. 5) Check the 12-month and 5-year rules before changing any existing election. 6) Build the cash reserve and diversify the low-basis stock. 7) In the move year, set up domicile evidence and file part-year resident returns.
| Task | Who does it | When |
|---|---|---|
| Read plan payout options | You, with HR benefits | Before annual election window |
| Choose 10-year equal installments | You | At each deferral election |
| Check old state's nonresident rules | Your CPA | A year before moving |
| Change an existing election | You, via plan administrator | 12+ months before first payment |
| Set up domicile evidence | You | Move year |
| Review cash reserve and stock sales | Your advisor | Every year |
A question for Mariner Wealth Advisors before your next election
Ask this: does each of my deferral-year elections qualify for the 10-year protection, and if not, can I still change it under 409A without hurting my cash needs? Bring the plan document, the election forms and the planned move date.
The schedule, not the new address, decides whether your old state can still tax each installment.
What people ask about deferred compensation moving states
What happens if my old state audits my residency after I move?
Can I change my deferred comp payout schedule after I've already elected it?
Is lifetime payout or 10-year installments better for avoiding my former state's tax?
Do 401(k) and IRA withdrawals follow the same state rule after a move?
What happens if my plan adds a larger final payment to a 10-year schedule?
How is the year I move taxed when I'm a part-year resident of two states?
Primary sources
This content is general information and education. It is not individual investment, tax or legal advice. Investing involves risk, including the possible loss of principal. Before making any financial decision about your equity awards or assets, consult a professional adviser who knows your full situation.