Mariner Wealth Advisors treats a Roth conversion in 2026 as a bracket-filling decision: convert only what fits under the 24% bracket's ceiling by December 31, and pay the tax from a taxable account. A conversion must be completed by December 31 to count for that tax year, and since 2018 it cannot be recharacterized, so the only adjustable part is next year's amount.
Where this actually shows up is small and ordinary: a CFO opens the custodian portal in the second week of December, sees the traditional IRA balance, and types a round number. The number is usually wrong, because it was sized from last April's tax return and not from this year's vests, planned stock sales and deferred comp installment.
These are the questions Mariner Wealth Advisors hears most often in first meetings with executives, and the arithmetic below is the part that gets skipped. All investing carries risk, and the value of what you convert can fall after you pay the tax on it.
By Sarah Chen, CFP — Senior Financial Planner | Reviewed by Linda Foster, CPASarah has guided families through retirement transitions for over fifteen years, specializing in tax-efficient withdrawal strategies.
We size the conversion from this year's booked income, never last April's return. The 8-cent step from 24% to 32% is paid the day the custodian processes the request, and no amended return takes it back.
Dana Whitfield, CPA and Tax Director, Mariner Wealth Advisors
Before 59½, withholding the tax from the conversion is the expensive convenience: a 10% penalty on every withheld dollar, plus a Roth that opens smaller than you planned.
Marcus Reyes, CFP® and Lead Advisor, Mariner Wealth Advisors
If your deferred comp installments fill the 24% bracket for the next eight years, there is no bargain to capture. Mark the year the schedule drops and convert then.
Priya Raman, Senior Financial Planner, Mariner Wealth Advisors
What does a December conversion actually buy you?
You pay tax on the converted amount this year at a rate you can read off the bracket table, and in exchange that money and its future growth are never taxed again. That is the whole trade. The price is the cash that leaves your taxable account to pay the tax and stops compounding there.
The move is permanent from the day the custodian processes it. Conversion income lands entirely in the year the custodian completes it, so a December instruction hits this year's return, not next year's.
Executives whose future income is already booked high gain the most. If your NQDC installments are scheduled and required minimum distributions start at 73 (75 if you were born in 1960 or later), your later brackets are partly spoken for. Someone whose rate will plainly be lower later should keep deferring.
The trade in one line
Who gains and who should wait
December 31 is the hard deadline. No extension applies, and the filing deadline in April has nothing to do with it.
Is the conversion worth doing at all this year?
Run three tests. First, after counting every booked dollar of this year's income, is there real room left under the 24% ceiling? Second, do you hold enough taxable cash to pay the tax without touching a retirement account? Third, will your payout years stack enough ordinary income that 24% looks cheap in hindsight?
If any one of those fails, the honest answer is a $0 conversion this December and a fresh look next October.
We would rather convert nothing in a year with no bracket room than convert out of habit, because the 8-cent step from 24% to 32% is paid immediately and never comes back.
- Room under the 24% ceiling after vests, planned sales and the NQDC installment
- Taxable cash on hand to cover the tax bill
- Future years that will be fuller than this one, not emptier
The limits, the dates, and the payout already on your calendar
Conversions have no income limit. Direct Roth IRA contributions are what get phased out — $242,000 to $252,000 on a joint return in 2026 — which is why high earners convert.
December is the heaviest week of the year at most custodians, and processing queues back up accordingly. Put the instruction in during the first half of the month, and ask your firm outright how many business days it needs.
Since 2018 there is no recharacterization. A conversion cannot be sent back to the traditional IRA.
Deferred comp is different. Pre-tax NQDC has no Roth side, so installments stay locked ordinary income and can't be converted. They still matter, because they occupy the same brackets the conversion is trying to fill cheaply. How NQDC payout elections shape your future brackets is worth mapping before you pick a conversion amount.
No income cap on conversions
Why your NQDC schedule sets the ceiling
Hypothetical: a $150,000 conversion that cost $6,000 extra
Natalie is 51, a CFO, married with two teenagers, and bound by a 5x-salary stock ownership guideline, so years of grants and open-market purchases have piled up as concentrated employer shares she is not free to sell down quickly. In December she converts $150,000, sized from last year's return. But this year already booked a $90,000 gain from planned stock sales plus an $80,000 deferred comp installment, so the last $30,000 of the conversion spills into the 32% bracket: $30,000 × 8% = $2,400 of extra tax. She also tells the custodian to withhold 24%, which is $36,000. That slice never reaches the Roth. It's a taxable distribution from her traditional IRA, and at 51 the 10% early-distribution penalty applies: $36,000 × 10% = $3,600. Combined avoidable cost: $6,000. Her Roth opens with $114,000 instead of $150,000. The fix is unglamorous: convert $120,000, pay about $28,800 of tax (24%) from the taxable brokerage account, and all $120,000 stays in the Roth.
Mariner Wealth Advisors prices the arithmetic before the amount, which is the reverse of how most December conversions get decided. The calculator on this site runs the same bracket-room math with your own numbers.
The detour
The fix, in numbers
| Item | Before (the detour) | After (the fix) |
|---|---|---|
| Conversion amount | $150,000 | $120,000 |
| Top dollars taxed at | 32% | 24% |
| Tax paid from | Withheld from the conversion | Taxable brokerage account |
| Roth balance on day one | $114,000 | $120,000 |
| Early-distribution penalty | $3,600 | $0 |
| Avoidable extra cost | $6,000 | $0 |
Two mistakes that travel together
Sizing a conversion from last year's tax return is the first. Every dollar that spills from 24% into 32% costs 8 cents the moment the custodian processes it.
Withholding the tax from the conversion itself is the second. Before 59½, that withheld slice is a taxable early distribution carrying the 10% penalty, and it permanently shrinks the Roth.
The two feed each other. An oversized conversion is usually what makes the withholding election look convenient in the first place: there isn't enough taxable cash to cover a number that was too big. In Natalie's case the pair costs $6,000 and leaves the Roth $36,000 short of what she intended.
Our decision rule is short. Fill, don't spill: size the conversion so the last dollar stays inside the 24% bracket after counting every source of income this year, vests, stock sales and NQDC installments included, and if you're under 59½, pay the tax from a taxable account rather than by withholding.
What can you still change after you convert?
Nothing about the conversion itself. It's irrevocable, with no undo. What stays adjustable is next December's amount, the source of the tax payment, and whether to convert at all in a given year.
One more clock runs in the background. Taxable portions of converted amounts withdrawn within five years carry the 10% penalty if you're under 59½, so money you might need soon doesn't belong in a fresh conversion.
Small annual conversions are the risk-management substitute for recharacterization. You cap the damage of any single wrong-sized year.
A conversion locks in today's rates with no way back. If your income could drop for several years, through a career break, a sabbatical or a sale event you can schedule, convert in small December increments and keep the larger amounts for a confirmed low-income year.
The five-year clock before 59½
Why smaller and annual beats one big year
When converting now is the wrong call
If your marginal rate already sits at 32% or higher, or your NQDC election schedule plus a pension will fill the 24% bracket for most of the next decade, converting now simply prepays tax at rates you may never reach. The top federal rate for 2026 is 37% above $768,700 on a joint return and $640,600 single, and nobody fills a bracket cheaply from up there.
Waiting costs nothing. Re-run the arithmetic each October, and when a genuinely low-income year arrives, do the conversion then.
Same move, two years apart. In 2027 Natalie's deferred comp installment steps up to $200,000 and planned stock sales add $150,000 of gains, so her taxable income already reaches the top of the 24% bracket. Converting $150,000 that year costs $150,000 × 8% = $12,000 more than converting the same amount at 24%. She converts nothing in 2027 and schedules $150,000 for 2029, the year her installment drops to $60,000 and the bracket room is real. Twelve thousand dollars apart, decided by confirmed income rather than any view on markets or legislation.
| Factor | Convert in 2027 | Convert in 2029 |
|---|---|---|
| NQDC installment | $200,000 | $60,000 |
| Planned stock-sale gains | $150,000 | Minimal |
| Room under 24% ceiling | None | Real |
| Top dollars taxed at | 32% | 24% |
| Extra tax on $150,000 | $12,000 | $0 |
| Decision | Skip | Convert |
The December order of operations
Four steps, done in this sequence before the December backlog builds.
Mariner Wealth Advisors clients usually find step one is the slow part, because booked income is scattered across a vesting schedule, a 10b5-1 plan and a deferred comp election made years ago.
- 1) With your CPA, list this year's booked income: vests, planned sales, the NQDC installment. Measure the room left under the 24% ceiling.
- 2) Choose the amount and the tax source. Taxable-account cash, not withholding.
- 3) Instruct the custodian in early December and ask how long its conversion processing takes.
- 4) File Form 8606 with the return, and expect the 1099-R in late January.
- Ask your CPA: how much room is left under the 24% ceiling after every booked income item?
- Ask your plan administrator: does my NQDC election schedule fill these same brackets in later years?
- Ask your custodian: will the conversion be processed in time if I instruct it this week?
- Ask about state tax: does my state tax the converted amount?
Three numbers Mariner Wealth Advisors sizes first
We start with booked income for the year measured against the 24% ceiling, then the pre-tax balances that could fund a conversion, then the taxable cash available to pay the tax.
That third number usually sets the size of the conversion more than any opinion about future tax rates does. If you'd like us to run it, describe your situation on the request form; the fee schedule goes out in writing ahead of the first meeting, and Mariner Wealth Advisors generally works with executives whose investable assets total $500K or more.
Fill, don't spill: the last converted dollar should stay inside the 24% bracket after every vest, sale and installment is counted.
What people ask about a Roth conversion in 2026
What happens if I convert more than the 24% bracket can hold?
Is there an income limit on a Roth conversion in 2026?
Can I undo a Roth conversion if the numbers look wrong in April?
Do I have to pay the conversion tax out of the Roth itself?
Will a December conversion raise my Medicare premiums two years later?
How does a conversion interact with my deferred comp payouts?
Can an adult child direct a conversion from a parent's IRA?
Why convert now if tax rates could be lower in ten years?
What paperwork follows a December conversion?
Primary sources
This content is general information and education. It is not individual investment, tax or legal advice. Investing involves risk, including the possible loss of principal. Before making any financial decision about your equity awards or assets, consult a professional adviser who knows your full situation.