A charitable remainder trust turns concentrated company stock into a yearly income stream without an immediate capital gains bill. Mariner Wealth Advisors weighs that trade-off against a plain staged sale before anything gets drafted. The trust has to pay out at least 5% and no more than 50% of its value a year, and the charity's projected remainder must be worth at least 10% of what you put in, or the trust fails at funding.
The urgency isn't a calendar date so much as a trading window: once shares move into the trust, the decision is done. If you're inside the last year before a sale window closes, or your health or your company's stock plan is changing, that's when this question usually needs an answer.
These are the questions Mariner Wealth Advisors hears most often in first meetings with executives who hold one stock worth more than they'd like to admit.
By Sarah Chen, CFP — Senior Financial Planner | Reviewed by Linda Foster, CPASarah has guided families through retirement transitions for over fifteen years, specializing in tax-efficient withdrawal strategies.
We'd rather fund a trust with less than the full position and keep two years of spending outside it, because the one thing you can't do in a bad year is ask for principal back.
Senior Financial Planner
The 10b5-1 window matters more than people expect. If a sale clears before the transfer agent retitles the shares, the gain lands on you personally, not the trust, and no amended filing fixes that.
CPA and Tax Director
At a 5% payout and 6% assumed growth, the capital gains tier on a $1,800,000 gain runs about 18 years. Move the return to 2% and those same payouts eat into principal years sooner.
CFP® and Lead Advisor
Two ways to unwind a $2 million position
Start with the numbers. $2,000,000 of stock with a $200,000 basis carries $1,800,000 of gain. Sell it in four stages of $500,000 a year and each sale realizes $450,000 of gain, taxed at 23.8%: $107,100 a year, $428,400 over four years.
Fund a 20-year unitrust with the same shares instead, and the trust sells inside its own wrapper with no tax due in the funding year. The year-one payout is 5% of $2,000,000, or $100,000.
The deferral is not free. The $2,000,000, plus whatever it earns above the payouts, goes to the named charity when the 20-year term ends. Victor and Jeanette's heirs get nothing from the trust itself, so the $428,400 of tax the staged sale would have cost is really being traded against a $2,000,000 remainder.
Markets can still fall after the shares are inside. A unitrust payout moves with account value, so neither route removes investment risk, and the money invested can lose value, including some of what was put in.
The staged sale's math
What the trust gives up
A charitable remainder trust must pay out 5% to 50% of its value each year, and the charity's projected remainder has to be worth at least 10% of the funding amount, or the IRS treats the trust as failed from day one.
What a 5% payout actually pays you
A unitrust revalues every January and pays the stated percentage of that new balance. A 20% market drop cuts next year's check by roughly a fifth. A charitable remainder annuity trust works differently: it pays a fixed dollar figure regardless of what the account does, which trades upside for certainty.
Payouts come out in a set order: ordinary income first, then capital gains, then tax-exempt income, then principal. With $1,800,000 of gain sitting in the capital gains tier, Victor and Jeanette's $100,000 payouts draw from that layer for roughly 18 years before anything else is touched.
One detail that moves the deduction: it's set by the IRS Section 7520 rate for the month shares are transferred, or either of the two prior months if you elect. Timing the funding month by even a few weeks can change the number on the return.
Unitrust versus annuity trust
Where the deduction comes from
Is an irrevocable trust still safe if health changes at 60?
No. Once shares are retitled into the trust, the principal is out of reach, even for a medical bill, and the payout rate and term are locked in at funding. That's the piece people underestimate going in.
What can still move: the trustee, the investments the trustee holds, and, if the trust document reserves the power, the named charity itself.
We'd rather fund less than the full position and keep two years of spending in cash and taxable shares outside the trust, because a bad year can't be covered from inside it.
Nothing resets after signing — there is no cooling-off window. Your one exit is to sell the income interest or hand it to the charity, and both of those end the payments without sending any principal back to you.
What's locked at signing
What stays flexible
Funding it in the right order
The sequence matters because company counsel and the 10b5-1 plan administrator both have to clear the share transfer, and that commonly adds weeks before a trading window closes.
Why timing gets tight
- 1. Decide the dollar amount you'd give away regardless of tax benefit
- 2. Pick unitrust or annuity trust and the payout rate
- 3. Have counsel draft the trust and sign it
- 4. Open the trust's brokerage account
- 5. Retitle shares through the transfer agent and get written confirmation of settlement
- 6. Let the trustee sell and diversify the proceeds
- 7. Claim the deduction on that year's return and track the 30%-of-AGI limit
Does the answer change for a single executive with $400,000 of stock?
Yes, usually toward not doing it. Below roughly $500,000 of stock, drafting, trustee and annual filing costs take a visible bite out of the benefit, and a staged sale or a donor-advised gift typically does more per dollar given.
Married couples can structure a two-life term so the survivor keeps the income after the first spouse dies. A single filer reaches the 37% top federal rate above $640,600 of taxable income sooner, which can make the deduction year worth more to them.
Funding while Victor's salary is still running puts the deduction against a high-income year. Funding after he stops work wastes part of the deduction against a smaller AGI, since the carryforward is limited to five years.
Jeanette's pension is really why they can afford to lock income away at all. Without a pension floor underneath, a smaller trust and more liquid cash outside it is the more honest answer.
Single versus married
Timing against your own income
Which income the payout counts against
Capital gain tiers carry the 3.8% net investment income tax, so a blended 23.8% rate applies to most of a unitrust payout for years.
Appreciated stock given to a trust with a public charity as remainder beneficiary is generally deductible up to 30% of AGI, with a five-year carryforward for anything unused.
Medicare sets the Part B premium from the tax return filed two years back, so the payouts that matter are the ones Victor takes at 63 and 64 — those are what price his premium at 65 and 66. The 2026 standard premium is $202.90 a month, and the first surcharge tier lifts it to $284.10. A $100,000 payout stacked on other income is enough to cross a tier for a couple, which is an argument for funding before the lookback years start counting.
Trust assets sit outside the taxable estate, which matters less against a $15,000,000 per-person estate tax exclusion. Income timing and tax deferral, not estate size, is the real reason to do this.
Capital gains and the 3.8% surtax
Medicare and the estate exclusion
| Assumption moved | Year-1 payout | What it does to the plan |
|---|---|---|
| Base case: 20 years, 5% | $100,000 | Gain layer lasts about 18 years |
| Trust returns 2% a year, not 6% | $100,000 | Later payouts shrink each year |
| Payout raised to 8% | $160,000 | 10% remainder test gets tight |
| Term cut to 10 years | $100,000 | Bigger deduction, charity paid sooner |
| Two-life term, not 20 years | $100,000 | Jeanette keeps income after Victor |
| Capital gains rates fall later | $100,000 | Staged sale closes most of the gap |
Run this against your own shares
Victor and Jeanette are a hypothetical. Your own version needs your basis by lot, your sale window and your charity, and the three assumptions that actually move the answer are the ones in the table: the payout rate, the term, and what the trust earns. Mariner Wealth Advisors runs the 10% remainder test and the gain-layer arithmetic on your real numbers before suggesting a rate or a term, because an 8% payout on a 20-year trust can fail the test outright.
- Share of net worth tied up in one ticker
- Cost basis by lot, not just an average
- Whether any shares are pledged against a loan line
- Whether the company is an S corporation, which disqualifies the trust and ends the S election
- Charitable giving in dollars over the past three years
- Expected AGI for the funding year
- Cash on hand outside the trust, measured in months of spending
- Who the successor trustee would be
Before shares leave your name
It's worth a conversation with Mariner Wealth Advisors when one position runs above about a fifth of your net worth, you already give to charity most years, and a sale window is coming inside the next year.
Bring the position's cost basis by lot, your trading window calendar, your most recent filed return, and the charity you'd name as remainder beneficiary. You'll see the fee schedule in writing before that first conversation, and Mariner Wealth Advisors works with investable assets starting at $500K.
Trust principal never comes back, so fund it with no more than the share of the position you'd already decided to give away.
What people ask about a charitable remainder trust company stock
How late in the year can a charitable remainder trust be funded and still count for that year's deduction?
Which suits low-basis company stock better, a unitrust or a charitable remainder annuity trust?
What happens if I need a large lump sum of cash five years into the trust term?
Can my children receive the payouts after my spouse and I have both died?
How much of my income can the deduction offset in the funding year?
What tax form does a charitable remainder trust send me each year?
Primary sources
This content is general information and education. It is not individual investment, tax or legal advice. Investing involves risk, including the possible loss of principal. Before making any financial decision about your equity awards or assets, consult a professional adviser who knows your full situation.